Tenant Screening Guide: Minimize Problems & Losses

We’ve discussed the importance of tenant screening in the past when it comes to strategies for landlords to avoid bad tenants. However, today, we’ll offer a far more in-depth look at the strategies you can employ to screen tenants. With better screening practices, you can not only minimize problems and avoid losses, but you’ll also maximize the ROI of your rental properties. 

This comprehensive tenant screening guide will explore each step of the tenant screening process, from initial application forms to making the final decision. After all, finding quality tenants is integral to maintaining the value of your rental property and ensuring a steady income from rent.

Why Tenant Screening is Crucial

Thanks to its multifaceted benefits, tenant screening is crucial for property managers and landlords. Beyond merely reducing risks, thorough vetting of prospective tenants is imperative for maintaining the integrity of the property and ensuring a harmonious living environment for all occupants. By meticulously assessing potential tenants, property managers can significantly mitigate the likelihood of encountering various challenges, such as property damage, legal disputes, and rental payment defaults.

Moreover, compliance with legal regulations is paramount in tenant screening. Landlords must meticulously follow the guidelines and regulations established by governing bodies to prevent potential discrimination lawsuits. By adhering to these legal requirements, property managers safeguard the rights of all applicants while upholding ethical standards in their rental practices.

Furthermore, effective tenant screening is pivotal in safeguarding the physical property and preserving its long-term value. Landlords who attract and retain tenants who demonstrate a commitment to maintaining their living space can ensure the upkeep of the property and foster a sense of community among residents. This enhances the property’s appeal and contributes to its sustained appreciation in value over time.

By the way, one surefire way to increase your pool of qualified applicants is to drastically reduce tenant moving costs with skip-the-deposit privileges from Rental Deposits Now.

Key Steps in Tenant Screening

Now, let’s take a closer look at the key steps involved in the tenant screening process:

Pre-Screening Process

Proper tenant screening begins before you even meet prospective tenants. The pre-screening phase involves application forms that collect pertinent information and credit and background checks.

Application Forms

Every prospective tenant should complete a rental application. This form gathers essential information, such as employment history, income, past rental experiences, and personal references. 

Credit Checks

A credit report will yield a snapshot of the applicant’s financial reliability. High credit scores often correlate with a history of paying rent on time.

Background Checks

Running a criminal background check can reveal past behaviors that may pose a risk to your property or other tenants. This check should be done with the applicant’s consent and in compliance with local laws.

Did you know Rental Deposits Now analyzes your tenant credit criteria and, in turn, tenant default exposure to build the right deposit-free program for you? Learn more!

Interviewing Potential Tenants

After the pre-screening, speak directly with candidates to clarify lease terms and communicate your expectations. This is also an opportunity to assess the potential tenant’s communication style and commitment to maintaining the property.

Verifying Information

It’s not enough to take an application at face value. Each piece of information should be verified, including:

Employment Verification

Confirm the applicant’s place of employment and income to ensure they can pay rent.

Rental History Checks

Contact previous landlords to learn about the applicant’s rental behavior, late payments, or potential damage to previous properties.

References

Speaking to professional or personal references can provide additional insights into the character and reliability of the applicant.

Legal Considerations

Stay in legal compliance throughout the tenant screening process. Always follow Canada’s fair housing laws, prohibiting discrimination based on race, religion, sex, or other protected classes. 

Making Informed Decisions

Weigh all factors—credit, employment, rental history, and references—against your criteria to make informed decisions about whom to rent to.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

In addition to the importance of thorough tenant screening, landlords should also be mindful of common pitfalls to avoid in their rental management practices. 

Skipping crucial screening steps, such as background checks and reference verifications, can leave landlords vulnerable to renting to unreliable or potentially problematic tenants. Ignoring red flags during the screening process, such as inconsistencies in rental history or employment information, can similarly result in future difficulties and conflicts.

This also brings us to staying up-to-date on current housing laws. Otherwise, failure to stay updated on tenant and housing regulations poses a significant risk for landlords. Changes in laws regarding tenant rights, eviction procedures, and fair housing practices can have profound implications for rental management.

Landlords who neglect to stay informed about these regulations may inadvertently violate the law, leading to legal repercussions and financial penalties that extend far beyond a tenant not paying their monthly rent.

Tenant Screening FAQs

Finally, here are a few frequently asked questions about tenant screening:

How do I screen a tenant?

Screening a tenant involves:

  • Collecting an application.
  • Conducting background and credit checks.
  • Verifying employment and rental history.
  • Interviewing the prospective tenant.

What is a tenant interview?

A tenant interview is a face-to-face meeting where landlords can ask questions, gauge the potential tenant’s character, and discuss lease terms.

What questions do you ask a potential tenant?

Ask about their reasons for moving, employment and income, rental history, and how they maintain their living space.

What are the red flags of a bad tenant?

Look out for inconsistencies in their stories, reluctance to provide details, a history of frequent moves, bad credit, or negative feedback from previous landlords.

Along with understanding how to perform tenant screening, remember: using the right selection techniques aligns with a well-managed tenant screening guide. Quality tenants are out there, and with the right process, you can fill your rental property with those who will treat it with care and respect, ultimately ensuring a steady income and less turnover for your investment.

Summary: Your Tenant Screening Guide

Thorough tenant screening is an indispensable practice for successful property management. By employing a careful and consistent screening process, property managers can protect their investments and secure quality tenants, who are more likely to maintain the property and fulfill their lease agreements. 

Although tenant screening requires effort and due diligence, its importance cannot be overstated. Follow these guidelines and make tenant screening an integral part of your rental agreement procedures to ensure a prosperous future for your rental business.

If you’d like to learn more about how Rental Deposits Now can help attract and retain quality tenants, schedule a demo today.

Did you learn a lot from this tenant screening guide?

Here are three more articles to read next:

infographic

Avoid Bad Tenants:
11 Pro Tips for Landlords